Underarm Crutches · Head-to-head

Sammons Preston Wooden Crutches vs Drive Medical Aluminum Underarm Crutches

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Commissions never change our scores. Details.

Our pick: the Drive Medical Aluminum Underarm Crutches edges it on overall Fit Score (7.6 vs 5.6), winning 5 of 5 categories. The right choice still depends on your priorities, the breakdown is below.

Sammons Preston Wooden Crutches

Sammons Preston

5.6/10 Fit Score

For buyers who specifically want wood. Heavier and slower to adjust than aluminum, but sturdy, latex-free, and rated to 350 lb, which beats the usual wood pair. Check the 49"–61" adjustment range against your height before ordering.

Check price on Amazon
Our pick

Drive Medical Aluminum Underarm Crutches

Drive Medical

7.6/10 Fit Score

The default pharmacy crutch and the best choice for most people: sturdy, easy to size, and cheap. For a few weeks of recovery it is all you need. If you will be on crutches for months or want more comfort, step up to one of the premium picks below.

Check price on Amazon

Category-by-category

Category Sammons Preston Wooden Crutches Drive Medical Aluminum Underarm Crutches
Comfort 6/10 7/10
Stability 7/10 8/10
Portability 4/10 6/10
Ease of use 5/10 8/10
Value 6/10 9/10
Overall Fit Score 5.6/10 7.6/10

Specs side by side

SpecSammons Preston Wooden CrutchesDrive Medical Aluminum Underarm Crutches
Weight capacity350 lb350 lb
MaterialWood (latex-free)Aluminum
Crutch heightAdjusts 49"–61" (adult size)
Height adjustmentWing-nut (hand grips adjust along with the height)Push-button (1" increments)
Fits user height5'2"–5'10" (Adult; youth & tall sizes sold separately)
Weight capacity350 lb350 lb
FoldsNoNo
Best forBest on a budgetShort-term recovery

Free guide

Still deciding between the two?

Grab our free buyer’s guide, the checklist we use to score every product, so you can make the call with confidence.

Before you go

Get our free underarm crutches Buyer’s Guide

The things that actually matter when choosing the right underarm crutches, plus our current top picks. One email, no spam.